When Your Biggest Customer Starts Shopping Around
What should you do when your biggest customer starts shopping around?
When your biggest customer starts getting other quotes, do not cut your price first. Find out what triggered the search, talk to the person who will make the decision, and learn what they would lose by leaving. Then put what only you do for them in writing, so someone other than you can defend your number.
You usually find out sideways. A buyer you have known for years asks for a cost breakdown they never needed before. A new name from purchasing shows up on the email thread. Someone on your floor hears that another shop was asked to quote your part. Nobody has said the account is in play, and everybody knows it is.
If that account is a third of your revenue, the week that follows is a hard one. This guide covers what to do in that week, what to ask the customer, and what to fix afterward so that one account never decides your year again.
Why your biggest customer is looking
Start here, because the reason changes the response. In most cases the search has little to do with anything you did.
Someone new is in the chair. A new purchasing manager or supply chain lead inherits your account with no history. Your twenty years of on-time delivery are a line in a spreadsheet to them. Rebidding the big suppliers is how a new person learns the category and shows the boss some savings.
There is a cost target. The customer has been told to take a percentage out of purchased parts this year. Every large supplier gets the same letter. It feels personal and it is arithmetic.
They want a second source. After a supply scare, many companies decide that no critical part should come from one supplier. They may have no intention of leaving. They want a backup qualified, and the backup has to quote to get qualified.
Ownership changed, on their side or yours. A new owner at the customer reviews every vendor. A new owner at your shop can trigger vendor requalification inside the customer's purchasing system. We covered that risk in our guide on how to announce new ownership to customers.
Your champion left. The engineer or buyer who knew why you were worth the money retired or moved on. The reasons went with them, because they were never written down anywhere.
That last one sits underneath most of the others. The case for your shop lived in one person's head on the customer's side, the same way it lives in one person's head on yours.
The first week
1. Find the trigger before you respond. Call the person you know best at the account and ask plainly what changed. Ask what is driving the review, who is running it, and when a decision is due. Most people will tell you, and the answer tells you which of the five reasons above you are dealing with.
2. Talk to the person who decides. That is often someone you have never met. Ask for thirty minutes, in person if you can get it. A supplier who shows up to understand the customer's problem is already different from the three shops that only sent a number.
3. Learn what leaving would cost them. Switching a critical supplier is expensive in ways a quote does not show. The new shop has to be qualified. First articles have to be approved. Tooling may have to move or be rebuilt. Someone has to carry extra inventory through the changeover, and someone's name is on the decision if the new parts are late. Never use any of this as a threat. Understand it, because it is part of what your price already covers.
4. Put your value on one page. The buyer has to defend the decision in a meeting you will not attend. Give them the page to do it with. Write down what you do for this customer that a new supplier would not do on day one, with the evidence. Delivery record. Quality record. The engineering changes you caught before they became scrap. The rush jobs you turned around. Use their part numbers and their language.
5. Answer the price question last. If the review turns up a real gap in your cost, close it. A customer who has paid too much for years will find out, and it is better that they hear it from you. If there is no real gap, hold your number and let the one-page case carry it. A discount offered in the first conversation tells the buyer your price was never real, and the next review will start from the lower one. We ran the arithmetic in our guide on how to stop competing on price in B2B. Ten percent off a job with a thirty percent margin takes a third of the profit.
Six questions to ask the customer
Take these into the meeting in step two. Listen more than you talk, and write down the answers word for word.
1. What is driving the review, and what would a good outcome look like for you?
2. Besides price, what are you comparing suppliers on?
3. What do we do well that you would not want to lose?
4. Where have we been harder to work with than we should be?
5. If you added a second source, which work would you keep with us?
6. What would you need from us to stop the search?
Question four is the hard one and the most useful. If there is a real service problem behind the search, you want to hear it now, from them, while you can still fix it.
What the scare is telling you
Whether you keep the account or not, the scare has shown you two things about your business.
The first is that the customer's loyalty was thinner than it felt. A shop owner on the Practical Machinist forum described the feeling for everyone who has been through it. "All of my customers are looking for the cheapest price, period. Nothing else seems to matter… Absolutely no loyalty whatsoever."
It feels like betrayal. In most cases it is something plainer. The customer was loyal to a person, a habit and a price, and one of the three changed. Nobody at that company could have told you, in one sentence, why your shop was worth more than the next one. If they could not say it, they could not defend it when the new purchasing lead asked.
The second is that too much of your year depends on one account. Owners know this long before the scare. Lenders and buyers of companies look hard at how much revenue sits with the largest customer, because they have seen what happens when it leaves.
Both problems have the same root. The company never decided, and never wrote down, who it serves best and what it does for them that nobody else can. Our guide to manufacturing branding explains how that decision gets made and what it is built from.
The ninety days after
Once the week is over, the instinct is to go buy leads. A new website, a sales hire, a list, an ad campaign. Anything that puts more quotes in the pipeline.
Hold that instinct for a moment. More leads of the same kind will bring you more customers who buy on price and leave on price. You would be rebuilding the same exposure with smaller accounts.
The work that reduces the risk is narrower.
Find your second-best and third-best customers. Look past the big account at the ones who pay well, stay, and rarely argue. Ask them the same six questions. Their answers will overlap, and the overlap is what you are known for.
Name the segment they belong to. Those customers have something in common. An industry, a kind of part, a tolerance, a run size, a need for engineering help. That is the market where your strengths are worth money.
Write the position down. Who you serve best, what you do that competitors cannot, and the proof. Our brand positioning for manufacturers page shows the five decisions that go into it.
Give it to the big customer too. The one-page case you wrote in week one is the first draft. A customer who can explain why you are worth more is a customer who can defend you in the next review.
This is the move we made with Croze Nest, an artisan barrel maker that was set up to compete with large factories on volume and price. The company stopped chasing the volume market and chose the craft and micro-distillers the factories ignored. It grew from selling one barrel to one customer to handcrafting more than 500 custom barrels a year. The full story is in the Croze Nest case study.
For a job shop or contract manufacturer, where every competitor runs the same machines, our post on how contract manufacturers differentiate works through the same steps.
If you lose the account anyway
Sometimes the decision was made before you heard about it. If the account leaves, three things are worth doing.
Ask for the exit conversation. Find out what they chose and why, and write it down. It is the most honest market research you will ever get.
Leave the door open and the relationship clean. New suppliers miss dates, and second sources become first sources again. The shop that handled the loss well is the first call.
Then do the ninety-day work above before you spend money on leads. The gap in revenue is real and urgent. Filling it with customers who value what you do is the only version that does not put you back in the same meeting two years from now.
Where we come in
We work with owner-led B2B manufacturers whose product is better than their win rate. The work is positioning. We take the business apart with you, find the segment that values you most and the thing you do that competitors cannot, and write it down so your whole company and your customers can repeat it.
Positioning takes about a month, and the price is on the page. Our brand positioning for manufacturers page covers what you get, who it is for and who it is not for.
If your biggest customer is shopping around right now, bring what you know to a thirty-minute call. We will tell you whether positioning is the problem and what we would do first. Book a call.
FAQ’s
-
Do not cut the price first. Find out what triggered the search, meet the person who will make the decision, and learn what switching suppliers would cost them. Then put what you do for that customer on one page, with the evidence, so the buyer can defend your number in a meeting you will not attend.
-
Only if the review shows a real gap in your cost. A discount offered in the first conversation tells the buyer your price was never real, and the next review starts from the lower number. Ten percent off a job with a thirty percent margin takes a third of the profit. Make the case for your value before you touch the price.
-
Usually for reasons on their side. A new purchasing lead wants to learn the category, the company has a cost-down target, they want a second source after a supply scare, or ownership changed. Often the person who knew why you were worth the money has left, and the reasons were never written down.
-
There is no single safe number, and it depends on your margins and how quickly you could replace the work. A useful test is whether losing the account would force layoffs or put a loan at risk. If it would, the account is too large a share, and reducing that dependence deserves a plan before the customer forces one.
-
Start with your next-best customers, the ones who pay well and stay. Find what they have in common and name that segment. Write down what you do for them that competitors cannot, with the proof, and aim your selling at more companies like them. More leads of any kind will only bring more customers who buy on price.
-
Ask for an exit conversation and write down what they chose and why. Leave the relationship clean, because second sources often become first sources again. Then decide who you serve best before you spend money on leads, so the revenue you rebuild comes from customers who value what you do.
