Why the Brand Positioning Process Is Hard. And Why That Means You're Doing It Right
Quick Answer: The brand positioning process feels hard because it requires identity-level decisions, not just marketing choices. Small business owners who struggle with brand positioning — circling back, second-guessing themselves, feeling stuck — are typically doing the work correctly. That discomfort signals deep strategic thinking. A structured process, like The Brand Lab™, channels that friction into clarity rather than eliminating it.
Quick Answer: The brand positioning process feels hard because it requires identity-level decisions, not just marketing choices. Small business owners who struggle with brand positioning — circling back, second-guessing themselves, feeling stuck — are typically doing the work correctly. That discomfort signals deep strategic thinking. A structured process, like The Brand Lab™, channels that friction into clarity rather than eliminating it.
"This is harder than I thought it would be."
Good.
If you've sat down to work on your brand's positioning and found yourself circling back, second-guessing everything, and wondering whether you're even on the right track — welcome. That's not a sign something is broken. That feeling is the signal that something real is happening.
Brand positioning isn't a marketing task. It isn't a content project. It's strategic identity work, and it's exactly as hard as it should be. This post explains why — and what to do with that difficulty.
What Is the Brand Positioning Process? (And Why Most Businesses Avoid It)
Brand positioning is the strategic process of defining how your business occupies a distinct, ownable space in your market and in your ideal clients' minds. It answers three foundational questions:
Who are you really for?
What do you genuinely stand for?
What are you willing to not be?
These aren't surface-level marketing questions. They are identity-level choices — and identity work doesn't happen in a clean, linear sprint. Most businesses avoid going this deep because they're busy, because it feels uncomfortable, or because they assume a logo and a tagline are sufficient. They're not.
Without a clear brand positioning strategy, small businesses default to competing on price — the most exhausting and least profitable place to compete. Prospects can't see what makes you different, so they compare you on cost. Every project becomes a negotiation. Every month feels like starting from scratch.
"Without clear positioning, you're seen as interchangeable. Price becomes the only differentiator."
Why Brand Positioning Work Is So Mentally Draining
Most small business owners expect brand strategy to feel like a creative exercise — some brainstorming, a mood board, a catchy tagline at the end. What they experience instead is something closer to an identity audit under a spotlight.
The brand positioning process drains you because it forces you to hold multiple things in your mind simultaneously: your clients' real problems, your competitive landscape, your own strengths and gaps, and a vision of what you want your business to stand for — and to make high-stakes decisions at the intersection of all of them.
One of our clients described it as "brain drain." That phrase stuck because it's accurate. The looping, the friction, the feeling of going backwards before you go forward — that's not a malfunction. That's integration happening.
The Three Hardest Questions in Brand Positioning
In our work with small business owners through The Brand Lab™, the questions that create the most productive friction are consistently the same:
"Who are we really for?" — Not everyone, not anyone who'll pay, but a specific, well-defined ideal client with a specific problem you solve better than anyone else.
"What do we actually stand for?" — Not your services list, but the belief or approach that underlies everything you do and that your ideal clients would pay a premium to access.
"What are we willing to not be?" — Possibly the hardest. Positioning always involves exclusion. The businesses that try to appeal to everyone end up meaning nothing to anyone.
These questions don't have obvious answers. Finding them requires honest reflection, competitive analysis, and the courage to make choices. That's work. It's supposed to feel like work.
What the Difficulty Is Actually Telling You
Here's the insight most branding conversations skip: if brand positioning feels easy, you're probably skimming the surface.
Generic answers come quickly. "We provide exceptional service." "We deliver quality." "We put clients first." These statements cost nothing to write and do nothing for your positioning, because every competitor can say the same thing.
The hard answers — the ones that feel uncomfortable to commit to, that force you to say "we're not for everyone," that require you to articulate a specific belief or approach — those are the ones that create real competitive separation. And those take time. They take looping back. They take the mental effort that leaves you tired.
The exhaustion is your brain integrating everything you know about your business and forcing it into something coherent. That's not a problem. That's the process.
We've watched consultants stop apologizing for their rates after one focused positioning session. Interior designers go from feeling like impostors to winning competitive bids with confidence. B2B service businesses shift from chasing clients to curating them. In every case, the breakthrough wasn't a clever line — it was a moment of genuine, hard-won clarity about what makes them different and why that matters.
How a Structured Process Turns Friction Into Clarity
Structure doesn't make brand positioning easy. It makes the difficulty directional.
Without structure, the circling-back is just spinning. With the right framework, each loop surfaces something new. The hard questions get asked in the right order, so your answers build on each other instead of canceling each other out. The friction is still there — but now it's producing something.
This is the core insight behind The Brand Lab™ by Wit & Craft. We didn't set out to remove the difficulty from brand positioning work. We set out to make sure the difficulty has a direction — so that the hard thinking leads to a clear, ownable position you can actually build a business around.
What Structured Brand Positioning Produces
When the process is structured well, small businesses come out the other side with:
A clear positioning statement that distinguishes them from competitors — not just descriptively, but strategically
Messaging that resonates with the right clients and repels the wrong ones
The confidence to name their price without the backpedal
A brand equity foundation that compounds — every piece of marketing, every client conversation, every proposal reinforces the same clear story
Clarity changes everything. It changes what you say yes to. It changes how you price. It changes how you show up in a room full of prospects. It changes how your clients talk about you to their networks.
If Positioning Feels Like a Mess Right Now, You're Not Doing It Wrong
If you're in the thick of brand positioning work and it feels messy, circular, and harder than you expected — take that as a positive signal.
You're not skimming. You're not settling for generic answers. You're doing the identity-level thinking that actually separates businesses in crowded markets. That takes the kind of effort that leaves you tired.
Keep going.
The businesses that push through the difficulty and commit to a clear position are the ones that stop competing on price, start attracting right-fit clients, and build the kind of brand equity that turns expertise into lasting market value.
Frequently Asked Questions About Brand Positioning
-
For small businesses, a structured brand positioning process typically takes 4 to 8 weeks when done properly. This includes competitive analysis, ideal client definition, differentiator development, and positioning statement refinement. Rushing the process usually produces generic positioning that doesn't create real competitive separation.ext goes here
-
Brand positioning is the strategic foundation — it defines who you're for, what you stand for, and how you're different from competitors. Brand identity is the visual and verbal expression of that strategy (your logo, color palette, tone of voice, etc.). Positioning comes first. Identity should flow from it. Many small businesses build an identity before establishing a clear position, which is why their branding feels generic or inconsistent.
-
Small businesses struggle with brand positioning for three main reasons: they lack a structured process to guide the thinking, they're too close to their own business to see it objectively, and they're often trying to appeal to too broad an audience. The result is positioning that either sounds like everyone else or says nothing at all. Working with a structured framework — or an experienced brand strategist — addresses all three.
-
Your brand positioning is working when: prospects qualify themselves before reaching out, price negotiations decrease because clients already understand your value, referrals become more frequent and better-fit, and you can describe what makes you different in a single clear sentence that your best clients would recognize and repeat.
-
Yes — with the right framework. The Brand Lab™ by Wit & Craft was built specifically to give small business owners the tools and guided process to do strategic brand positioning without needing a full-service agency. The key is having a structured methodology that asks the right questions in the right order, rather than relying on templates that produce generic outputs.
Ready to Work Through the Hard Parts?
Every week, we share practical frameworks to help small business owners uncover what makes them different and build lasting brand equity around it. If you're ready to move from confusion to clarity:
Join the newsletter — weekly brand positioning insights and frameworks delivered to your inbox.
Book a Brand Lab™ discovery call — a short conversation to explore what's holding your positioning back and what's possible on the other side.
If a 5th grader can't understand it, it's not ready
Quick test: Imagine you're at a coffee shop. Someone asks what you do.
Can you explain it in one sentence—without jargon, buzzwords, or qualifiers—and have them immediately understand?
If not, you've got work to do.
Quick test: Imagine you're at a coffee shop. Someone asks what you do.
Can you explain it in one sentence—without jargon, buzzwords, or qualifiers—and have them immediately understand?
If not, you've got work to do.
I call this the Coffee Shop Test.
And most founders fail it spectacularly.
Read these three before/after examples:
Before: "We provide enterprise-grade, cloud-based solutions that leverage AI-driven analytics to optimize stakeholder engagement across multiple touchpoints."
After: "We help companies talk to their customers better using smart software."
Before: "We're a consultative partner that facilitates transformational outcomes through strategic alignment and cross-functional synergy."
After: "We help leadership teams get on the same page so they can execute faster."
Before: "We deliver bespoke, full-stack implementations with end-to-end lifecycle management."
After: "We build custom software and make sure it actually works for your team."
Notice the pattern?
The "before" versions sound impressive. They use all the right industry terms. They signal sophistication.
And they say absolutely nothing.
The "after" versions? A 5th grader could understand them. Which means a busy executive who's scanning your website for 8 seconds can understand them too.
Here's the rule: If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it clearly enough yourself.
And if you don't understand it clearly, how can your clients?
This isn't about dumbing things down. It's about respecting your audience's time and attention. It's about saying what you mean instead of hiding behind corporate speak.
Your expertise is real. Your solutions are valuable. Don't bury them under a pile of meaningless words.
Try this exercise right now:
Write down how you currently describe what you do
Read it out loud
Ask yourself: Would a smart 10-year-old understand this?
If not, rewrite it in simple, direct language
Keep going until you can say it clearly. Then say that everywhere.
Why Your "Why" Matters More Than Your What
I was halfway through explaining what we do at Wit & Craft to a potential client when I realized something unsettling: I was boring myself. Here I was, rattling off our services—brand strategy workshops, positioning frameworks, messaging development—and watching their eyes glaze over in real time.
I was halfway through explaining what we do at Wit & Craft to a potential client when I realized something unsettling: I was boring myself. Here I was, rattling off our services—brand strategy workshops, positioning frameworks, messaging development—and watching their eyes glaze over in real time.
That's when it hit me. I wasn't telling them why we do this work. I was just listing the what.
Purpose Cuts Through the Noise
In Start with Why, Simon Sinek writes, "People don't buy what you do; they buy why you do it." It's a simple statement that cuts to the heart of why so many businesses struggle to connect with their audience. When we lead with our what—our products, services, features—we're essentially asking people to make a rational decision. But decisions, especially the important ones, aren't made rationally. They're made emotionally, then justified with logic.
Your why is your emotional hook. It's the reason you get out of bed in the morning that goes deeper than paying the bills. For us, it's watching small businesses stop apologizing for their prices and start owning their value. It's seeing entrepreneurs finally articulate what makes them special instead of blending into the background noise of their industry.
When you lead with purpose, something magical happens: the right people lean in. They don't just want your service—they want to be part of your mission.
Trust Is Built on Belief, Not Features
I've watched countless businesses try to build trust by listing their credentials, showing their portfolio, or explaining their process. These things matter, but they don't create the kind of deep trust that turns prospects into advocates.
Trust is built when someone believes you share their values. When they sense that you're not just trying to sell them something, but that you genuinely care about the same things they do. Your why is the bridge that connects your values to theirs.
Sinek puts it perfectly: "When a company clearly communicates their WHY, what they believe, we're drawn to give them our time and money for the same reason we're drawn to people with similar beliefs and values."
This is why purpose-driven brands create such fierce loyalty. Their customers aren't just buying a product—they're joining a movement, supporting a belief system, becoming part of something bigger than a transaction.
The Long Game: Purpose Fuels Resilience
Here's what I've learned after two decades in this business: trends come and go, markets shift, competition emerges, but purpose endures. When you're clear on your why, every decision becomes easier. Should we take on this client? Does this opportunity align with our purpose? Are we staying true to what we believe?
Your why becomes your North Star, especially during the inevitable rough patches. When revenue dips or a competitor launches something that makes you question everything, your purpose reminds you what you're really building. It's not just a business—it's a mission.
I think about the small businesses we've worked with who've transformed not just their positioning, but their entire relationship with their work. They stopped chasing every opportunity and started attracting the right ones. They stopped competing on price and started competing on purpose. That's the power of getting clear on why you do what you do.
Finding Your Why Isn't Always Easy
I won't pretend this is simple. Your why might not be immediately obvious, especially if you've been buried in the day-to-day grind of running a business. It requires honest reflection, sometimes uncomfortable questions, and the willingness to dig deeper than the surface-level reasons.
But here's what I know: your why is already there. It's in the moment you decided to start your business. It's in the clients who light you up and the problems you can't help but solve. It's in the vision of the world you want to help create.
The question isn't whether you have a purpose—it's whether you're brave enough to own it and build your brand around it.
So here's my gentle challenge: Before you write another service description or update your LinkedIn bio, sit with this question: Why do you really do what you do? Not the practical reasons, but the deeper ones. The ones that make your work feel like more than just work.
Your future customers are waiting to hear it.
Your Next Move
The Real Reason Your Prospects Go Silent After Your Proposal.
Close more clients
If your leads are ghosting you after the proposal, it's not your pricing. It's your positioning.
The silent killer of B2B growth isn't what most founders think.
It's not bad leads.
It's not market saturation.
It's not even your competition undercutting you on price.
It's the gap between what you think you're communicating and what prospects actually hear.
You've polished your website. Refined your pitch deck. Maybe even hired a copywriter to "fix your messaging." But prospects still vanish after seeing your proposal. They don't return calls. They choose competitors whose work isn't even close to yours.
Here's the brutal truth: Most founders confuse having clear messaging with having relevant positioning. They're not the same thing. And this confusion is costing you deals you should be winning.
The Messaging Mirage
Picture this: You can articulate exactly what you do. Your elevator pitch is crisp. Your website copy flows beautifully. Everything feels "clear."
But clarity without relevance equals invisibility.
Think of it like GPS navigation. You can give someone perfectly clear directions: "Turn left at Main Street, go 2.3 miles, turn right at the gas station." Crystal clear, right? But if they're trying to get to the airport and you're directing them to the mall, clarity doesn't matter. They're going to the wrong place.
Most B2B messaging suffers from this same problem. It clearly explains what you do—but fails to connect with what prospects actually need. It describes your services without revealing why those services matter to them, specifically.
This is why messaging without positioning falls flat. You're giving clear directions to a destination your prospects don't want to visit.
Three Pain Signals Your Positioning Is Missing
The Proposal Black Hole
You have great conversations. Prospects seem engaged. You submit a detailed proposal... and then silence. They don't say no—they just disappear. This isn't a pricing problem; it's a positioning problem. Without clear differentiation, your proposal looks identical to every other option. There's no compelling reason to choose you, so they choose nothing.
The Wrong-Fit Client Magnet
You keep attracting clients who want cheap, fast, and generic work. They negotiate hard on price and don't value your expertise. This happens when your positioning is too broad or too weak. You're not repelling the wrong prospects, so they flood your pipeline and drain your energy.
The Competitor Confusion
Prospects constantly ask how you're different from [insert competitor name]. Or worse—they lump you in with firms whose work you don't respect. When you can't quickly articulate what makes you unique, prospects default to comparing you on price. And price wars are races to the bottom.
The Fix: Building Your Positioning Foundation
Here's where most B2B founders get it wrong: They start with messaging before they've done the positioning work.
Think of positioning like an iceberg. Messaging is the tip—what people see. But positioning is the massive foundation below the surface. Without that foundation, your messaging has nothing to stand on.
The Brand Lab™ framework follows a simple but powerful sequence:
Discover → Define → Declare
Discover: Before you can position yourself effectively, you need to understand the landscape. Who are you really competing against? What are prospects' actual pain points? Where are the gaps in the market? This isn't guesswork—it's strategic research that reveals opportunities.
Define: Once you understand the market, you can identify what makes you genuinely different. Not just "better"—different. Different approaches, different expertise, different results. This is where you discover your unique competitive advantage.
Declare: Finally, you translate those differentiators into a clear market position. This becomes the foundation for every piece of messaging, every proposal, every conversation. It's your North Star.
The Transformation: From Price Competition to Premium Positioning
Take Dru Chapman Lewis from Studio Chapman. Before working with Brand Lab™, she felt trapped: "I had no idea, or confidence, how to differentiate myself and my company. I know, sort of instinctually, that I have a unique value proposition, but didn't feel I had the tools or the methodology to create that kind of brand awareness."
Sound familiar?
After going through the positioning process, everything changed.
"I scored a top client! It definitely gave me the confidence to stand my ground and get the fee based on my unique value perspective and positioning."
The difference? She stopped competing on price and started competing on value. She went from defending her worth to commanding premium rates.
That's the power of strong positioning. It transforms how prospects see you—and how you see yourself.
Your Next Move
If any of those pain signals resonated, here's what you need to do:
Stop trying to fix your messaging.
Start building your positioning foundation.
The good news? You don't need to figure this out alone. We've created a Brand Health Score Card that reveals exactly where your positioning might be falling short—and what to fix first.
Score your brand and get a clear diagnosis of your brand's positioning gaps.
Because here's the thing: Your expertise is probably extraordinary. Your results speak for themselves. But if prospects can't see what makes you different, they'll never choose you over the competition.
Time to change that conversation.
